Thursday, August 19, 2010
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Rethinking Development and the State: Reflections of the Late Tony Judt
Source: http://dinmerican.wordpress.com/2010/08/16/rethinking-development-and-the-state-reflections-of-the-late-tony-judt/
August 16, 2010
http://www.nybooks.com
Ill Fares the Land
April 29, 2010
by Tony Robert Judt FBA (January 2,1948 – August 6 2010)
Something is profoundly wrong with the way we live today. For thirty years we have made a virtue out of the pursuit of material self-interest: indeed, this very pursuit now constitutes whatever remains of our sense of collective purpose. We know what things cost but have no idea what they are worth. We no longer ask of a judicial ruling or a legislative act: Is it good? Is it fair? Is it just? Is it right? Will it help bring about a better society or a better world? Those used to be the political questions, even if they invited no easy answers. We must learn once again to pose them.
The materialistic and selfish quality of contemporary life is not inherent in the human condition. Much of what appears “natural” today dates from the 1980s: the obsession with wealth creation, the cult of privatization and the private sector, the growing disparities of rich and poor. And above all, the rhetoric that accompanies these: uncritical admiration for unfettered markets, disdain for the public sector, the delusion of endless growth.
We cannot go on living like this. The little crash of 2008 was a reminder that unregulated capitalism is its own worst enemy: sooner or later it must fall prey to its own excesses and turn again to the state for rescue. But if we do no more than pick up the pieces and carry on as before, we can look forward to greater upheavals in years to come.
And yet we seem unable to conceive of alternatives. This too is something new. Until quite recently, public life in liberal societies was conducted in the shadow of a debate between defenders of “capitalism” and its critics: usually identified with one or another form of “socialism.” By the 1970s this debate had lost much of its meaning for both sides; all the same, the “left–right” distinction served a useful purpose. It provided a peg on which to hang critical commentary about contemporary affairs.
On the left, Marxism was attractive to generations of young people if only because it offered a way to take one’s distance from the status quo. Much the same was true of classical conservatism: a well-grounded distaste for over-hasty change gave a home to those reluctant to abandon long-established routines. Today, neither left nor right can find their footing.
For thirty years students have been complaining to me that “it was easy for you”: your generation had ideals and ideas, you believed in something, you were able to change things. “We” (the children of the Eighties, the Nineties, the “Aughts”) have nothing. In many respects my students are right. It was easy for us—just as it was easy, at least in this sense, for the generations who came before us. The last time a cohort of young people expressed comparable frustration at the emptiness of their lives and the dispiriting purposelessness of their world was in the 1920s: it is not by chance that historians speak of a “lost generation.”
The Young are at a loss
If young people today are at a loss, it is not for want of targets. Any conversation with students or schoolchildren will produce a startling checklist of anxieties. Indeed, the rising generation is acutely worried about the world it is to inherit. But accompanying these fears there is a general sentiment of frustration: “we” know something is wrong and there are many things we don’t like. But what can we believe in? What should we do?
This is an ironic reversal of the attitudes of an earlier age. Back in the era of self-assured radical dogma, young people were far from uncertain. The characteristic tone of the 1960s was that of overweening confidence: we knew just how to fix the world. It was this note of unmerited arrogance that partly accounts for the reactionary backlash that followed; if the left is to recover its fortunes, some modesty will be in order. All the same, you must be able to name a problem if you wish to solve it.
I wrote my book Ill Fares the Land for young people on both sides of the Atlantic. American readers may be struck by the frequent references to social democracy. Here in the United States, such references are uncommon. When journalists and commentators advocate public expenditure on social objectives, they are more likely to describe themselves—and be described by their critics—as “liberals.” But this is confusing. “Liberal” is a venerable and respectable label and we should all be proud to wear it. But like a well-designed outer coat, it conceals more than it displays.
A Liberal and A Social Democrat
A liberal is someone who opposes interference in the affairs of others: who is tolerant of dissenting attitudes and unconventional behavior. Liberals have historically favored keeping other people out of our lives, leaving individuals the maximum space in which to live and flourish as they choose. In their extreme form, such attitudes are associated today with self-styled “libertarians,” but the term is largely redundant. Most genuine liberals remain disposed to leave other people alone.
Social democrats, on the other hand, are something of a hybrid. They share with liberals a commitment to cultural and religious tolerance. But in public policy social democrats believe in the possibility and virtue of collective action for the collective good. Like most liberals, social democrats favor progressive taxation in order to pay for public services and other social goods that individuals cannot provide themselves; but whereas many liberals might see such taxation or public provision as a necessary evil, a social democratic vision of the good society entails from the outset a greater role for the state and the public sector.
Understandably, social democracy is a hard sell in the United States. One of my goals is to suggest that government can play an enhanced role in our lives without threatening our liberties—and to argue that, since the state is going to be with us for the foreseeable future, we would do well to think about what sort of a state we want. In any case, much that was best in American legislation and social policy over the course of the twentieth century—and that we are now urged to dismantle in the name of efficiency and “less government”—corresponds in practice to what Europeans have called “social democracy.” Our problem is not what to do; it is how to talk about it.
The European dilemma is somewhat different. Many European countries have long practiced something resembling social democracy: but they have forgotten how to preach it. Social democrats today are defensive and apologetic. Critics who claim that the European model is too expensive or economically inefficient have been allowed to pass unchallenged. And yet, the welfare state is as popular as ever with its beneficiaries: nowhere in Europe is there a constituency for abolishing public health services, ending free or subsidized education, or reducing public provision of transport and other essential services.
Taking on Conventional Wisdom
I want to challenge conventional wisdom on both sides of the Atlantic. To be sure, the target has softened considerably. In the early years of this century, the “Washington consensus” held the field. Everywhere you went there was an economist or “expert” expounding the virtues of deregulation, the minimal state, and low taxation. Anything, it seemed, that the public sector could do, private individuals could do better.
The Washington doctrine was everywhere greeted by ideological cheerleaders: from the profiteers of the “Irish miracle” (the property-bubble boom of the “Celtic Tiger”) to the doctrinaire ultra-capitalists of former Communist Europe. Even “old Europeans” were swept up in the wake. The EU’s free- market project (the so-called “Lisbon agenda”); the enthusiastic privatization plans of the French and German governments: all bore witness to what its French critics described as the new ” pensée unique.”
Today there has been a partial awakening. To avert national bankruptcies and wholesale banking collapse, governments and central bankers have performed remarkable policy reversals, liberally dispersing public money in pursuit of economic stability and taking failed companies into public control without a second thought. A striking number of free-market economists, worshipers at the feet of Milton Friedman and his Chicago colleagues, have lined up to don sackcloth and ashes and swear allegiance to the memory of John Maynard Keynes.
This is all very gratifying. But it hardly constitutes an intellectual revolution. Quite the contrary: as the response of the Obama administration suggests, the reversion to Keynesian economics is but a tactical retreat. Much the same may be said of New Labour, as committed as ever to the private sector in general and the London financial markets in particular. To be sure, one effect of the crisis has been to dampen the ardor of continental Europeans for the “Anglo-American model”; but the chief beneficiaries have been those same center-right parties once so keen to emulate Washington.
No Re-thinking the State
In short, the practical need for strong states and interventionist governments is beyond dispute. But no one is “re-thinking” the state. There remains a marked reluctance to defend the public sector on grounds of collective interest or principle. It is striking that in a series of European elections following the financial meltdown, social democratic parties consistently did badly; notwithstanding the collapse of the market, they proved conspicuously unable to rise to the occasion.
If it is to be taken seriously again, the left must find its voice. There is much to be angry about: growing inequalities of wealth and opportunity; injustices of class and caste; economic exploitation at home and abroad; corruption and money and privilege occluding the arteries of democracy. But it will no longer suffice to identify the shortcomings of “the system” and then retreat, Pilate-like, indifferent to consequences. The irresponsible rhetorical grandstanding of decades past did not serve the left well.
We have entered an age of insecurity—economic insecurity, physical insecurity, political insecurity. The fact that we are largely unaware of this is small comfort: few in 1914 predicted the utter collapse of their world and the economic and political catastrophes that followed. Insecurity breeds fear. And fear—fear of change, fear of decline, fear of strangers and an unfamiliar world—is corroding the trust and interdependence on which civil societies rest.
All change is disruptive. We have seen that the specter of terrorism is enough to cast stable democracies into turmoil. Climate change will have even more dramatic consequences. Men and women will be thrown back upon the resources of the state. They will look to their political leaders and representatives to protect them: open societies will once again be urged to close in upon themselves, sacrificing freedom for “security.” The choice will no longer be between the state and the market, but between two sorts of state. It is thus incumbent upon us to reconceive the role of government. If we do not, others will.
The Way We Live Now
All around us, even in a recession, we see a level of individual wealth unequaled since the early years of the twentieth century. Conspicuous consumption of redundant consumer goods—houses, jewelry, cars, clothing, tech toys—has greatly expanded over the past generation. In the US, the UK, and a handful of other countries, financial transactions have largely displaced the production of goods or services as the source of private fortunes, distorting the value we place upon different kinds of economic activity. The wealthy, like the poor, have always been with us. But relative to everyone else, they are today wealthier and more conspicuous than at any time in living memory. Private privilege is easy to understand and describe. It is rather harder to convey the depths of public squalor into which we have fallen.
Private Affluence, Public Squalor
No society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far greater part of the members are poor and miserable. —Adam Smith
Poverty is an abstraction, even for the poor. But the symptoms of collective impoverishment are all about us. Broken highways, bankrupt cities, collapsing bridges, failed schools, the unemployed, the underpaid, and the uninsured: all suggest a collective failure of will. These shortcomings are so endemic that we no longer know how to talk about what is wrong, much less set about repairing it. And yet something is seriously amiss. Even as the US budgets tens of billions of dollars on a futile military campaign in Afghanistan, we fret nervously at the implications of any increase in public spending on social services or infrastructure.
To understand the depths to which we have fallen, we must first appreciate the scale of the changes that have overtaken us. From the late nineteenth century until the 1970s, the advanced societies of the West were all becoming less unequal. Thanks to progressive taxation, government subsidies for the poor, the provision of social services, and guarantees against acute misfortune, modern democracies were shedding extremes of wealth and poverty.
To be sure, great differences remained. The essentially egalitarian countries of Scandinavia and the considerably more diverse societies of southern Europe remained distinctive; and the English-speaking lands of the Atlantic world and the British Empire continued to reflect long-standing class distinctions. But each in its own way was affected by the growing intolerance of immoderate inequality, initiating public provision to compensate for private inadequacy.
Over the past thirty years we have thrown all this away. To be sure, “we” varies with country. The greatest extremes of private privilege and public indifference have resurfaced in the US and the UK: epicenters of enthusiasm for deregulated market capitalism. Although countries as far apart as New Zealand and Denmark, France and Brazil have expressed periodic interest in deregulation, none has matched Britain or the United States in their unwavering thirty-year commitment to the unraveling of decades of social legislation and economic oversight.
In 2005, 21.2 percent of US national income accrued to just 1 percent of earners. Contrast 1968, when the CEO of General Motors took home, in pay and benefits, about sixty-six times the amount paid to a typical GM worker. Today the CEO of Wal-Mart earns nine hundred times the wages of his average employee. Indeed, the wealth of the Wal-Mart founder’s family in 2005 was estimated at about the same ($90 billion) as that of the bottom 40 percent of the US population: 120 million people.
The UK too is now more unequal—in incomes, wealth, health, education, and life chances—than at any time since the 1920s. There are more poor children in the UK than in any other country of the European Union. Since 1973, inequality in take-home pay increased more in the UK than anywhere except the US. Most of the new jobs created in Britain in the years 1977–2007 were at either the very high or the very low end of the pay scale.
The consequences are clear. There has been a collapse in intergenerational mobility: in contrast to their parents and grandparents, children today in the UK as in the US have very little expectation of improving upon the condition into which they were born. The poor stay poor. (See Figures 1 and 2.) Economic disadvantage for the overwhelming majority translates into ill health, missed educational opportunity, and—increasingly—the familiar symptoms of depression: alcoholism, obesity, gambling, and minor criminality. The unemployed or underemployed lose such skills as they have acquired and become chronically superfluous to the economy. Anxiety and stress, not to mention illness and early death, frequently follow.
Income disparity exacerbates the problems. Thus the incidence of mental illness correlates closely to income in the US and the UK, whereas the two indices are quite unrelated in all continental European countries. Even trust, the faith we have in our fellow citizens, corresponds negatively with differences in income: between 1983 and 2001, mistrustfulness increased markedly in the US, the UK, and Ireland—three countries in which the dogma of unregulated individual self-interest was most assiduously applied to public policy. In no other country was a comparable increase in mutual mistrust to be found.
Even within individual countries, inequality plays a crucial role in shaping peoples’ lives. In the United States, for example, your chances of living a long and healthy life closely track your income: residents of wealthy districts can expect to live longer and better. Young women in poorer states of the US are more likely to become pregnant in their teenage years—and their babies are less likely to survive—than their peers in wealthier states. In the same way, a child from a disfavored district has a higher chance of dropping out of high school than if his parents have a steady mid-range income and live in a prosperous part of the country. As for the children of the poor who remain in school: they will do worse, achieve lower scores, and obtain less fulfilling and lower-paid employment.
Inequality is corrosive
Inequality, then, is not just unattractive in itself; it clearly corresponds to pathological social problems that we cannot hope to address unless we attend to their underlying cause. There is a reason why infant mortality, life expectancy, criminality, the prison population, mental illness, unemployment, obesity, malnutrition, teenage pregnancy, illegal drug use, economic insecurity, personal indebtedness, and anxiety are so much more marked in the US and the UK than they are in continental Europe. (See Figures 3, 4, and 5.)
The wider the spread between the wealthy few and the impoverished many, the worse the social problems: a statement that appears to be true for rich and poor countries alike. What matters is not how affluent a country is but how unequal it is. Thus Sweden and Finland, two of the world’s wealthiest countries by per capita income or GDP, have a very narrow gap separating their richest from their poorest citizens—and they consistently lead the world in indices of measurable well-being. Conversely, the United States, despite its huge aggregate wealth, always comes low on such measures. We spend vast sums on health care, but life expectancy in the US remains below Bosnia and just above Albania. (See Figure 6.)
Inequality is corrosive. It rots societies from within. The impact of material differences takes a while to show up: but in due course competition for status and goods increases; people feel a growing sense of superiority (or inferiority) based on their possessions; prejudice toward those on the lower rungs of the social ladder hardens; crime spikes and the pathologies of social disadvantage become ever more marked. The legacy of unregulated wealth creation is bitter indeed.1
As recently as the 1970s, the idea that the point of life was to get rich and that governments existed to facilitate this would have been ridiculed: not only by capitalism’s traditional critics but also by many of its staunchest defenders. Relative indifference to wealth for its own sake was widespread in the postwar decades. In a survey of English schoolboys taken in 1949, it was discovered that the more intelligent the boy the more likely he was to choose an interesting career at a reasonable wage over a job that would merely pay well.2 Today’s schoolchildren and college students can imagine little else but the search for a lucrative job.
How should we begin to make amends for raising a generation obsessed with the pursuit of material wealth and indifferent to so much else? Perhaps we might start by reminding ourselves and our children that it wasn’t always thus. Thinking “economistically,” as we have done now for thirty years, is not intrinsic to humans. There was a time when we ordered our lives differently.
—This essay is drawn from the opening chapter of Tony Judt’s newly published book, Ill Fares the Land (Penguin).
1.The best recent statement of this argument comes in Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett, The Spirit Level: Why Greater Equality Makes Societies Stronger (Bloomsbury Press, 2010). I am indebted to them for much of the material in this excerpt.↩
2.See T.H. Marshall and Tom Bottomore, Citizenship and Social Class (London: Pluto, 1992), p. 48.↩
Sunday, August 15, 2010
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
Speakers blame NEP vestiges
They result in slow development, symposium told
PETALING JAYA: Speakers from the civil society, business lobby groups and academia who took part in a symposium on the 10th Malaysia Plan (10MP) yesterday pointed out that vestiges of the New Economic Policy (NEP) were making the country falling behind in terms of socio-economic development.
They pointed out that ethnic-based affirmative policies, which had pervaded policy and decision-making over the past four decades, had also polarised the country.
The symposium, which saw Minister in the Prime Minister’s Office Senator Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon as the keynote speaker, was jointly organised by Asian Strategy & Leadership Institute, Centre for Pubilc Policy Studies and the American Malaysian Chamber of Commerce (Amcham).
Speakers at the first session were also pessimistic about whether the political will was there to drive reforms in order to make the country more competitive.
Amcham president Datuk Nicholas Zefferys summed up the system of preferences given to bumiputra companies, oligopolies, cartels, price controls and subsidies as an “NEP run amok”.
He said in the symposium’s first session that the situation had led to a negative perception of Malaysia by foreign companies, with many complaints over the years on how foreign companies had to go through bumiputera-owned companies in order to do business with government-linked companies (GLCs).
“An example is how a US company which wanted to supply products to the Government saw the original contract value rise to US$300mil from US$30mil via such business arrangements,” Zefferys said.
He said the fall in private sector investment over the years could be attributed to the “crowding out” of the private sector by state investment firm Khazanah Nasional Bhd and GLCs.
Zefferys said Malaysia was more ethnically polarised today as people were “not living side-by-side comfortably,” changes must come via redefining affirmative action, government decentralisation and strengthening the rule of law.
Koh said the challenges that came with a multi-ethnic and multi-religious society had to be seen more positively.
He said what was new in the 1Malaysia concept embodying national unity and efficient governance was the emphasis on outcome instead of input.
Koh said as part of the move to make the government machinery less wasteful, RM24bil was shaved off Budget 2010 mostly in operating expenditure compared with Budget 2009 while the 10MP’s budget allocation had been kept to the same amount as the 9MP’s.
“The political will is only as strong as the political endorsement,” he said, adding that the Government could not afford to ignore critical views on the ground despite the obstacles.
Among other speakers, Universiti Malaya’s Professor Edmund Terence Gomez said the weakness of property rights in the country made both locals and foreigners fear investing in the country.
“I believe the Government knows what needs to be done but can they deliver?” he asked.
There were still questions over whether the 30% equity policy would continue to be implemented, he said, adding that other critical issues were reform of the education system and the public sector.
Gomez also said it was “not possible” to have market-friendly affirmative action as it would not work in business. “We need to confront this clearly and openly,” he said.
Time running out for M’sian economy
| CPI Writings |
| WRITTEN BY DR LIM TECK GHEE |
| TUESDAY, 03 AUGUST 2010 10:37 |
More evidence has just come in that time is running out for the country to get its basics right if the Malaysian economy is to grow at a respectable pace.
According to the United Nations’ World Investment Report 2010, foreign direct investment (FDI) for Malaysia has plunged 81 percent from US$7.32 billion (RM23.47 billion) in 2008 to just US$1.38 billion (RM4.43 billion) last year.
This is further confirmation that despite the many efforts to court foreign investors to invest here, the foreign and local business community is not buying what is being sold to them in terms of the attractiveness of Malaysia as a place to do business.
The latest data must be especially a letdown for Prime Minister Najib Razak who has been active on the international front, attending investor meetings and courting foreign fund managers and foreign business leaders to persuade them to put their money in Malaysia.
There are various important points that we can deduce from the data in the table, and other tables in the report comparing the Malaysia inflows with other countries in the SE Asian region.
o The downturn in FDI is not a one or two year phenomenon but a long term trend. The previous attraction that we had for foreign investors is no longer there, and this is likely to continue in the foreseeable future.
o The trend is not only of diminishing FDIs into Malaysia but for us to do worse than the rest of our neighbors in the region. In 2008 we accounted for 15.5% of FDI flows into SE Asia; in 2009 it was down to 3.7%.
o Short of a complete breakdown in the governments in neighboring countries such as Singapore, Thailand, Indonesia and Vietnam, we are looking at foreign investors preferring to invest in these countries rather than Malaysia.
o Even if political turmoil and social instability appears to be more pronounced in countries such as Thailand, we are no longer able to compete with them for FDI.
o The outflow of domestic investments is a new trend. This suggests that the country is unable to develop new industries or sustain existing industries to prevent local funds from leaving the country. It also indicates loss of confidence by local business in the country’s economy and politics.
What are some of the implications of this trend of diminished FDI flows?
Obviously, if it is not reversed, it will result in less high quality employment generated. The chain effect is more than just jobs lost for Malaysians. It also means that local suppliers will lose out; services such as catering, transport, etc will have a smaller clientele; and the government will collect less in terms of business and income tax and other taxes. In other words, the country may well end up poorer; much poorer.
Even if local businesses step in to fill some of the gap, they will not be able to make up for the loss. Unlike other countries such as Taiwan or South Korea, few import-substituting domestic industries in Malaysia have become world-class export industries. The undeniable fact is that most world-class exporting firms in Malaysia are foreign-owned or joint-venture ones with foreigners providing the crucial technological and market know-how and cutting edge.
Back to the drawing board on FDIs
What this means is that the country needs to go back to the drawing board if it wants to compete for FDI or even to ensure that domestic investors do not flee the country (as they are already doing in droves).
In the past, we have relied on a range of perks to attract foreign investors including tax-free pioneer status; investment tax allowances; reinvestment allowances, etc. We had also in the 1980s and 90s a head start over countries in attracting FDI due to our superior infrastructure and – at that time – our more competitive labour force.
All this has now been eroded. There is similar tax concessions found all over the world.
Furthermore, our electricity and water utility costs are beginning to soar, and our worker productivity has stagnated in comparison with other countries whilst wages have gone up.
It does not require rocket science to recognize what is holding back investors – whether foreign or local. They include
• NEP requirements and barriers
• Rising costs of production leading to lower profits
• Low levels of efficiency arising from lack of worker skills, poor R&D and low technological capacity
Most damaging of all to business and investor confidence (although not easily quantifiable) is the rising racial and religious ranting from Malay extremists. Although mainly conducted in the Malay media and targeted at Malay audiences, the new wave of emotive breast-thumping (and occasional posturing with the keris) in the name of Malay dominance and Malay unity surely has not gone unnoticed.
Besides reading the internet news portals for a more accurate gauge of what is taking place in the politics and economics of the country, many savvy business leaders keep close tabs on what is put out in the Utusan Malaysia and Berita Harian, as well as over the government Malay language electronic media.
Government dithering on NEM
Foreign investors may initially have been encouraged by the launching of the NEM and would have harboured hopes that this would mean a new economic era of liberalization and higher competitiveness for Malaysia.
The NEM has been silent on any mention of the NEP and has called instead for “market friendly”, “merit-based”, “transparent” and “needs-based” policies. Investors would have inferred from the lack of mention of the NEP in the NEM that this 40-year-old socioeconomic policy would finally be laid to rest.
However, like others, they are now nonplussed by the government’s dithering on whether or not to finally abandon this anachronistic policy. They would undoubtedly be especially troubled by the remarkable ability of the Prime Minister to sing a different tune on the subject depending on his audience.
Adding to their worry would be the Prime Minister’s speech at the closing ceremony of the first Malay Consultative Council (MPM) congress held at the PWTC on May 30 where Najib stated that the NEM is a “trial balloon” and the policy has yet to be finalized.
Attaining Vision 2020
In another recent speech, the PM has also begun to back off from his earlier confident claim that the country would be able to achieve Vision 2020 by clarifying that the external economic environment may well derail the achievement of key targets such as per capita income and others.
Of course, foreign investors understand that the external environment, external factors and foreign investors can help the country in its realization of Vision 2020 and the NEM’s goals.
However, I am sure they will beg to differ with the Prime Minister’s assessment of the critical importance of the external environment. Many amongst them will emphasize that it is the internal environment and internal factors – in particular the politicking (and associated rent-seeking) by Umno – that holds the key to the economic fortunes of Malaysia.
Note: An earlier version of this appeared in Chinese in the paper, the Red Tomato.
Tuesday, August 3, 2010
Figures that matter
By DR FONG CHAN ONN
sunday@thestar.com.my
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2010/6/27/nation/6558595&sec=nation
The reported CPI in Malaysia has been increasing by about 3% per annum for the last three decades, while the world CPI has gone up 3,000 times over the same period. A more realistic mechanism for the computation of CPI is needed in an open and globally connected economy like ours.
MUCH has been articulated about how the Consumer Price Index (CPI) is not reflective of the purchases of ordinary Malaysians any more. This is especially true for the low to middle income wage earners, where the bulk of the population sits.
The reported CPI in Malaysia has been increasing by about 3% per annum for the last three decades, while the world CPI has gone up 3,000 times over the same period (see table on the far right). So much so that housewives scoff when they are told that prices of goods and services are only increasing at 3% a year.
Taxi drivers scream every time their vehicles are up for a service because they are charged for spare parts and servicing, which go up by at least 10% annually.

Their scepticism stems not from disbelief in the institution’s calculation but the sheer stress that they have to bear from having to make ends meet, particularly those living in the urban areas.
It also makes the ordinary citizens think that politicians and policy-makers are completely disconnected from the realities of Malay sian life, cocooned in making decisions that do not reflect the hardship they have to bear.
Employers and trade unions, when making yearly adjustments to wage levels, use the CPI as the basis for salary increments. Trade unions’ grouses are justified in the case of arguing that wage levels are not enough for a typical household to survive. However, they are equally frustrated with the system, as there is no other index or basis for greater wage increments.
It must be recognised that the “middle income trap” is, in fact, directly due to the way the CPI is being skewed and suppressed.
The table above shows the breakdown of the weightage allotted for the various broad categories of items consumed on a daily basis.
“Food and non-alcoholic beverages” and “Housing, water, electricity, gas and others fuels” make up over 52.8% of the weightage. Without going into the finer details of what the actual items are in these two categories, it is suffice to say that most of the items are either heavily subsidised or price controlled, like sugar, flour, water, petrol, electricity and so forth.
The dislocation in the CPI and the real prices paid by a household becomes more obvious when we consider that we do not just consume flour and sugar in its raw form, but in value-added items like cooked food and beverages. Eating out in coffee-shops or warung certainly include prepared items such as cooked fish, vegetable and prawns which are always levied at market prices but not captured in the CPI.
Transport, which makes up 15.9% of the weightage, does not take into account hire purchase for cars or motorcycles or the cost of imported spare parts for their repair.
Construction materials such as cement and clinker may be price controlled but the prices of houses and rental are determined at market rates, which are not subjected to regulations.
Mobile devices have become an integral part of our daily lives. Most of us have to pay bills for SMS, telephone calls and data download that are not included in the communication category.
The impact of an artificially low inflation rate is as follows:
> Important business decisions are based on the inflation rate, and this can mislead the private sector into making business judgments that are off the mark, costing the economy billions in losses.
> It leads to wages being artificially suppressed, creating a widening income gap between Malaysians working domestically and those working outside the country. This, in turn, exacerbates the “brain drain” problem.
> With low wages, we are not able to attract outside talent into Malaysia even though our goods and services are supposedly cheaper.
> It creates a technology gap, making Malaysia uncompetitive. Technology goods and services become expensive for Malaysians to purchase, including things like iPhones, Blackberry, and iPads which are soon becoming everyday items.
> We will have to depend on a low foreign exchange rate to ensure that Malaysian goods remain competitive but this is an unsustainable strategy in the long run.
> With a cheap currency, we cannot afford to purchase the most advanced machinery and technology, leading to poor fixed asset/capital build-up. This also explains part of the problem of sluggish private sector investments.
The implication of having an unrealistic CPI is a very serious matter and cannot be brushed aside as mere grumblings of the rakyat. However, just like in the treatment of the removal of subsidies and price controls, proper safety nets must be in place to protect the lower income and vulnerable groups.
The general price levels of the basket of goods and services will no doubt adjust itself as subsidies and controlled items are subsequently removed but this has to be done gradually to prevent hyper-inflation.
And additional items such as communication devices and computers will have to be introduced to reflect a more competitive and advanced Malaysia.
Next to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), the CPI is probably the most important economic indicator that all governments use to gauge the health of an economy. As the CPI is the basis of many policy benchmarks with very far-reaching implications in the management of an economy and the wealth of a nation, a strong case of a more realistic mechanism for the computation of CPI is timely and much needed in an open and globally connected economy like Malaysia.
> Tan Sri Dr Fong Chan Onn was Prof of Applied Economics and Dean of Faculty of Economics and Administration, Universiti Malaya. He served in the Government as Deputy Minister of Education (1990-1999) and as Minister of Human Resources (1999-2008). Currently, he is the MP for Alor Gajah.
Monday, August 2, 2010
Resolve widening income disparity gap now
Source: http://www.consumer.org.my/development/socio-economic/458-resolve-widening-income-disparity-gap-now
The difference between what the rich and the poor earn (the income disparity gap) remains wide and needs the government’s urgent attention.
In a fair and just society, economic growth should benefit everyone. Unfortunately this is not happening in Malaysia in spite of years of economic growth. We have now an aristocracy of wealth where a small group of Malaysians are very rich (22 billionaires at the last count) whilst many others are barely scrapping by. We have on one hand people living in spacious multi-million ringgit homes whilst on the other hand there can be as many as 21 people crammed together in a low cost flat.
The statistics prove that the inequality gap is a major problem:
- The bottom 40% of households have an average income of RM1,222 whilst the top 20% households earn an average of RM8,157
- 58% of households earn less than RM3,000 per month. (In 2009, the government decided that any urban household with less than RM3,000 would be considered poor)
- Income growth has been strong only for the top 20% of Malaysian income earners, particularly since 1990
- The disparity within the urban group remains high with no improvements in the last decade
In 2007, Malaysia’s Gini coefficient was 0.441 in 2007, an improvement of 0.462 was made in 2004. However in 1990, the Gini coefficient was 0.442, which means that we have hardly made any progress in addressing the problem of income inequality since that time. (Gini coefficient is a measure of inequality ranging from 0 to 1, with 0 representing absolute equality and 1 representing absolute inequality);
Much needs to be done to enable both the rural and urban poor to break from the vicious circle of poverty. Being poor, they face problems relating to nutrition, health and education. A significant portion of Malaysian children are undernourished with about 15% found to be underweight and stunted. When these children grow up without good academic qualifications, they end up with jobs that do not pay decent wages. They remain poor like their parents and so will their children and grandchildren unless the chain of poverty is broken.
It is not only a question of equity that all Malaysian should get to share the country’s economic growth. If the problem of economic disparity is not seriously looked into, it will lead to social problems for example increase in crime rates. Furthermore, the more equal societies grow faster than less equal ones.
The unresolved income disparity gap clearly shows that we have a structural problem. We should stop pursuing the model of economic development imported from the west but instead adopt a model which meets our own needs and beneficial to all sectors of the population
Thus the government should be spending more money on education and health care programmes specifically designed to help the poor. It should also decrease disparities between rural and urban investments by ensuring that employment opportunities are more widely available in the rural areas.
Funds that are needed to run programmes to narrow the income inequality gap should come from the very rich, who after all have a moral obligation to help their less fortunate country men.
We recommend the following taxes be used to narrow the income inequality gap:
a) Inheritance tax/estate duty
Introduce either inheritance tax (which will be paid by the beneficiaries) or estate duty (which is paid by the deceased’s estate). Many countries (for example the USA, UK France, Germany, Netherlands and Canada) have implemented either the inheritance tax or the estate duty. Malaysia too had the estate duty until it was repealed in 1991.
The proposed inheritance tax /estate duty should have a low starting threshold and a progressive structure. Such a tax will help the country move towards a just society.
b) Personal tax
The government should stop reducing the personal income tax rate for the higher income earners. It should instead increase the rates to collect more funds for income redistribution.







